Can local players save Haiti after embarrassing 5-1 loss to Curaçao? | ANALYSIS

CAP-HAÏTIEN — Haiti’s national soccer team experienced one of its most humiliating defeats in recent memory, falling 5-1 to Curaçao in a World Cup qualifying match on Tuesday, June 10 at Trinidad Stadium in Oranjestad, Aruba. The blowout triggered outrage and renewed calls for changes to the team’s composition and management—particularly a demand for the inclusion of local-based players and Johnson Jeudy, a playmaker in the Jamaican first division.

“You guys are not ashamed not to put the local players and Johnson Jeudy?” Les Grenadiers fan, Saincy Dieudonne, wrote on Facebook after the loss. “Long live the production of local players and the few ones with quality in the diaspora.” 

The debate over local versus foreign-based players is hardly new, but this match amplified it. At its core, it reflects a larger national struggle: who gets to represent Haiti, who gets excluded, and why. The anger isn’t just about soccer—it’s about a country where local leadership often rejects external help but still fails to deliver internally.

Yet, Haiti’s humbling loss to Curaçao in the World Cup qualifiers has reignited the polarizing debate over local versus foreign-based players. But framing the issue around player origin alone oversimplifies a much deeper set of systemic failures: weak preparation, a crumbling domestic league, ineffective coaching and persistent exclusion of the diaspora. Haiti’s soccer woes mirror the country’s broader governance dysfunction, where local leadership resists diaspora input yet depends on their financial support. Unless these structural issues are addressed, any solution—local or international—will remain out of reach, not just in sports.

A team falling apart despite recent victories

Regardless of where the players come from, what’s clear is that this Haitian team is not functioning. Haiti, historically one of the Caribbean’s top teams, looked amateurish against a still-developing Curaçao side. Poor passing, disorganized defense, lack of urgency—the problems were systemic.

Star striker Duckens Nazon was ineffective. Team co-captain and central defender Ricardo Adé’s misguided back pass to veteran goalkeeper Johny Placide led to the fifth goal, a mistake unworthy of international competition. It was a collapse not just in skill but in discipline and preparation.

Critics argue that even in recent wins against weaker teams, warning signs were obvious. Haiti’s national team, despite moments of brilliance, has lacked consistency, cohesion and strategy. With this Summer’s Gold Cup looming and another World Cup qualifying round coming in September, this team needs urgent restructuring.

The Jeudy question: Hope or hype?

Johnson Jeudy has become a symbol in this debate, hailed by many as a missing piece. The 26-year-old midfielder dazzled for Real Hope Football Academy in recent years in Haiti’s makeshift championship and now plays in Jamaica. Yet his record is modest: five games with no goals or assists for Mount Pleasant FA. His magic on the ball is undeniable, but he has not proven himself in high-level competitions.

In the Concacaf Caribbean Cup, Jeudy impressed against lower-tier teams. But in the Champions Cup, against Mexico’s Cruz Azul, he was outmatched. His team lost 7-0 over two legs, controlling just 38% of possession in the second game. He’s talented, but his experience doesn’t yet justify a spot in Haiti’s senior team.

Meanwhile, Haitian midfielders like Danley Jean-Jacques—Major League Soccer’s Philadelphia Union— and Dany Jean—Portugal’s second division— are delivering results at a higher level. They are more consistent and competitive, even if their stats aren’t explosive.

Jean-Jacques is a starter with the Philadelphia Union, racking up three assists and two goals in 14 games so far this season.

As for Jean, he has recorded two goals and two assists in 14 games for Sport Clube União Torreense in Portugal’s second division. Furthermore, the midfielders on the roster have numbers that may not be impressive, but they are still better than Jeudy’s, and they are performing at a higher level with consistency in recent years. 

Jeudy also had a stint with Cunupia Football Club in Trinidad and Tobago during the 2023-24 season, and like his time in Jamaica so far, he failed to impress. 

A Broken domestic league: It should not be just about pride, but also about readiness

Calls for more local players overlook the reality that Haiti’s domestic league is in crisis. Years of gang violence and instability have left the league barely operational. In 2024, only a fraction of clubs participated. The top scorer, América des Cayes’ Ernst Clerger, managed just six goals; this season’s leader, Violette Athletic Club’s Roberto Jean, scored five.

Defenders and goalkeepers, too, underperform internationally. Colo Myson and Gooly Elien shined in the local season but struggled in regional tournaments. The talent pool is shallow, the competition weak.

Compare this to the early 2000s, when local players like Peter Germain, Monès Chèry and Alexandre Boucicaut emerged from a functioning Haitian league and went on to succeed internationally. Today, that infrastructure is gone.

The temptation to see local players as national saviors stems from pride and frustration. But pride alone doesn’t win matches. The league must first become competitive again before its stars can compete at the international level.

There’s also scapegoating at play. Fans angry over diaspora inclusion are missing the bigger picture: Haiti’s federation lacks resources, its coach (Sébastien Migné) lacks strong international results, and its players lack preparation. Leadership—in football and politics—tends to resist change unless it serves their interests.

As one local media analyst put it: Sportingly, Haiti was stronger when there was regular competition, a functioning soccer federation and a good mixture of locals and expatriates training together. Until Haiti rebuilds its football structure, that golden balance remains a memory.

The post Can local players save Haiti after embarrassing 5-1 loss to Curaçao? | ANALYSIS appeared first on The Haitian Times.